death and the maiden ending analysis


date the date you are citing the material. His main character has the choice to kill her worst enemy or to set him free. Death and the Maiden Study Guide Widely considered to be Ariel Dorfman 's most influential play, Death and the Maiden explores the challenges of restoring democracy and stability to a country recovering from an oppressive military dictatorship. Death and the Maiden ( Der Tod und das Mdchen in German) was a common motif in Renaissance art, especially painting and prints in Germany. Death and the Maiden Marianne Stokes, 1908 95 cm 135 cm Death and the Maiden is a Pre Raphaelite Oil on Canvas Painting created by Marianne Stokes in c. 1908. The mirror coming down is a device which implicates them in the moral dilemma. Disch, Thomas M. Review of Death and the Maiden in the Nation, May 11, 1992, pp. Death and the Maiden essays are academic essays for citation. Source Download See Death and the Maiden in the Kaleidoscope Created by the original team behind SparkNotes, LitCharts are the world's best literature guides. A few months later, the action shifts to a concert hall (with the mirror still in position). His brother, a member of the secret services, had convinced him that his involvement would be vengeance for what happened to their father, who had suffered a heart attack when peasants attacked his land. Some social reforms were achieved in the 1960s, but Chile's politics became increasingly polarized and militant Salvador Allende crept to presidential victory in 1970 with a leftist coalition of socialists, communists, and extremists. Gale Cengage So far, so terrible. Chilean society continues to struggle with the violent legacy of its past, although current president Eduardo Frei has sped the process of reconciliation by accelerating human rights tribunals and inquiries into Chile's "disappeared" (through commissions like the one to which Gerardo has been appointed in Death and the Maiden). Depravity: moral corruption. Modern Latin America, fourth edition, Oxford University Press (New York), 1997. LitCharts Teacher Editions. It is a problem play in the Henrik Ibsen tradition but just as clearly a revenge drama in the Elizabethan mold, with a touch of the film Fatal Attraction (1987). She stuffs her underwear into his mouth, takes his car keys and drives his car somewhere. Late that night, Gerardo and Paulina are awakened by a knock at their doorjust the kind of knock they feared during the earlier regimes reign of terror, and continue to fear. She does not speak in this final scene. Schroeder further explains that the connection with Schubert's work is also better understood in relation to Schubert's belief in the impossibility of returning to life "as it was before" after destructive episodes. How is the theme of justice portrayed in death and the maiden? Death and the Maiden was made into a film by Roman Polanski in 1994, starring Sigourney Weaver. This was first expressed clearly in paintings around five hundred years ago, and was revived during the late nineteenth century. This play consists of only three characters: Paulina Salas the protagonist, Gerado . A fully realistic play would present some kind of resolution to the dramatic conflict but this is hardly possible in Death and the Maiden. Paulina refuses to put down the gun, explaining that Roberto is the doctor who played Schubert. Even though she was blindfolded when she was raped and tortured, she claims to unmistakably recognize Robertos voice. These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of Death and the Maiden by Ariel Dorfman. Death and the Maiden 1994 R 1 h 43 m IMDb RATING 7.3 /10 25K YOUR RATING Rate Play trailer 1:55 1 Video 60 Photos Drama Mystery Thriller A political activist is convinced that her guest is a man who once tortured her for the government. A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. The opening moments of "Death and the Maiden" are so intriguing that almost any continuation would be a disappointment - but movies have to be about something, and so slowly the purity of the situation settles down into the business of the plot. As soon as Gerardo leaves, Paulina turns on Roberto,announcingher intent to kill him. 4. Critics have not been so focused on applying labels to Dorfman's theatrical technique, perhaps because they do not consider Dorfmanan intellectual and academic internationally known for his essays, novels, and poetryto be primarily a playwright. 18 Jan. 2023 , Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. It is harder to interpret how Paulina is coping with the aftermath of the events from a few months before. Gerardo is spoon-feeding soup to Roberto, while Paulina watches on from the terrace. But not before the woman, played by Sigourney Weaver, has made an indelible impression. date the date you are citing the material. The opening of the "Death and the Maiden" song. Students also viewed Robert North - Death and the Maiden hollyggeorgia44 The Polanski film Death and the Maiden is a wonderful and intelligent interpretation of Ariel Dorfman's human rights problem play. The lights come up and its nearly dawn. Furious, she demands to know why it must always be people like her - the victims - who have to restrain themselves. Death and the Maiden quotes and analysis. 4. (U.S. support of the coup through the Central Intelligence Agency [CIA] has been documented.) Paulina represents all victims that had suffered torture and abduction from a past dictatorship. Dorfman completed his schooling at the University of Santiago. She instructs Gerardo to go and fetch Robertos car. PAULINA (very calm, till the end of the scene): We can heat it up. Instead of purging the emotions and restoring order, Death and the Maiden raises questions and introduces uncertainty at every level, probing such issues as honesty in people, both with themselves and others, and effective solutions to dual psychological and political dilemmas. Rich, Frank. Several months later, Gerardo's career is clearly going well, and the Investigating Commission is, at least in his mind, a success. Though she is hesitant about the fact the commission will only look into cases in which victims are dead and is equally concerned that the commission will not have powers to prosecute, she tells him to take the position. Who do you say is right, Paulina or Roberto? The Handmaid's Tale season 4 has been one of change. The legacy of Evita (she died of cancer in 1952), combined with the knowledge that Peron was alive in exile, empowered many to adhere to Peronist ideals, despite the military's attempts to suppress them. The Handmaid's Tale season 4 ends with June Osborne killing Fred Waterford; here's everything that happens to reach that point, and what it means. Sweet is the treading of wine, and sweet the feet of the dove; But a goodlier gift is thine than foam of the grapes or love. He plays the part of good cop in order to elicit from her the story that will become Robertos confession. Politics of the Periphery and Theater of the Metropolis" in Comparative Drama, Vol. Paulina and Gerardo are attending a concert. eNotes.com Dorfman, Ariel. Death and the Maiden is at once a whodunit and a psychological thriller. 2003 eNotes.com Support your answer with two examples from Death and the Maiden. Under a constitution written during his regime, Pinochet himself remained army commander until stepping down in March, 1998. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class.. Composed in 1824, some four years before his death, Franz Schubert's Fourteenth String Quartet, also known as Death and the Maiden, remains one of the pillars in Western chamber music. The mirror is also the element which separates the play from its realistic form and structure; it leaves the audience with a powerful image at the conclusion of a play whose central conflict remains otherwise unresolved, "Death and the Maiden - Literary Style" Drama for Students In Death and the Maiden, a play that ran at the Little Theater from April 10-13, there is a loaded gun that never goes off, both literally and metaphorically: a trial that does not get a conviction. (including. Because Paulina will free the doctor only if he confesses to having committed wrongs of which he claims his innocence and ignorance, Gerardo believes it necessary to betray Paulina in order to save her, his innocent guest, his newly elected government, and his own ideals and career. Paulina doesn't react at first, but then she slowly turns to see Roberto, who has not taken his eyes off her. This essay will explore the nature of hysteria and its place and purpose in the play, and how Chile's neighbor, Argentina, has likewise seen frequent suppression of democratic processes. Gerardo claims he is holding off on taking the job until he has Paulinas approval. Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. Gerardo blames Paulina for the spare tire in their car being flat and quibbles with her over his missing car jackwhich she has loaned to her mother. The woman is full of fear, gripped by a secret . In one of the plays most startling moments, with the stage darkened, Paulinas harrowing narrative of abuse segues into Mirandas contrite narrative of abuse inflicted. Fujimori's actions are celebrated internationally, but nagging issues remain, including damaged relations with Japan (who had pushed for a peaceful negotiation to end the standoff), and accusations that Fujimori has used government intelligence forces to investigate political opponents. The Maidens are named after Persephone, the goddess of death. Contents 1 Plot 2 Cast 3 Production 4 Music 5 Reception 5.1 Critical reception She explains that her torturers had tried to get her to give up the name of whoever was fucking herGerardobut that she had successfully resisted. Gerardo explains to Roberto that he thinks the only way for Roberto to free himself is to indulge Paulinahe needs to confess, even if he is innocent. Bear, Jessie. Act 1 Scene 1 stage directions: sound of the sea. Indeed, the play suggests precisely the difficulty of resolving the social issue which is at its heart: how can a society reconcile itself with its violent past and, somehow, move forward? Novelist Rafael Yglesias (Fearless) and Dorfman wrote the screenplay based on the original play. Summary Tony award-winning Glenn Close, Richard Dreyfuss and Gene Hackman starred on Broadway in this political thriller. New York: Penguin, 1994. Roberto sees Paulina as unreasonable and insane. Once again, the play departs slightly from the hyper-realism of the earlier scenes by suggesting that Paulina and Gerardo watch this concert from seats in the actual audience. As a theme in visual art, Death and the Maiden is considerably more common, but concerns a peculiar association, that of death with the erotic. Schubert Quartet D. 810, "Death and the Maiden". The dictatorship that plagued her land has just fallen, and everything is uncertain. Word Count: 431. 87-88. She required power in order to manipulate her husband, Gerardo, to play along with her "game" and she believed that the power to instil fear in Roberto would bring her strength to punish him and bring closure to her life. 2 Act I, Scene 1 Sound of the Sea. The United States, who disproved of Allendes government, is alleged to have supported and even aided Pinochets actions in the takeover. Death and the Maiden Summary and Analysis of Act 1, Scene 1 Summary: The play takes place in the living/dining room and terrace of the Escobars' beach house. "Magical Opportunism'' in the New Yorker, March 30, 1992, p. 69. Struggling with distance learning? Guzman's more recent work also includes the film Chile: The Persistent Memory. In an interview in the London Times, Dorfman said, in reference to the audience, that Death and the Maiden "is not a play about somebody else, it's a play about them." He describes the success of the Investigating Commission in highly positive terms, emphasizing the generosity of the victims and of those testifying. Contents 1 Characters 2 Synopsis 3 Productions 4 Film adaptation 5 Opera Although Gerardo tries to physically force Paulina to free Roberto, she maintains a firm hold on hergun and threatens to shoot Roberto and herself unless Gerardo backs off. (Brief pause.) The last date is today's Welcome to the LitCharts study guide on Ariel Dorfman's Death and the Maiden. She had cunning political instinct, upon which Peron grew to rely. It lives at the Musee d'Orsay in Paris. An interview with Dorfman in which the playwnght discusses Chile's transition to democracy and his own plays Reader and Death and the Maiden. The marital tension increases as Paulina in turn accuses him of lying to her, pretending to need her approval, her yes, before accepting the commission appointment that he has already accepted. Death and the Maiden book. Its already after midnight; the wind is making the curtains billow and the sounds of the sea can be heard. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class.. What different forms of power are conveyed in Death and the Maiden? Instead, in The Maidens, the secret society in question involves a group of well-connected young women who flock around their favorite professor the handsome and possibly murderous Professor Fosca. The work was first performed in a private house, and was not published until 1831, after Schubert's death. At the story's end it is May again. Paulina, who is convinced that Roberto was the rapist (from her memory) kidnapped and technically forced a confession out of him. Gerardo acts as the voice of reason to emphasize Paulina's irrational and crazed tendencies in the play. As the lights go down, she turns her head and faces the mirror while the music plays on. Try it today! The usual form shows just two figures, with a young woman being seized by a personification of Death, often shown as a skeleton. Appalled by what his unrecognizable, pistol-wielding wife has done yet powerless either to stop her or to convince her of the harm she is doing to herself and their cause (as well as his career), Gerardo reluctantly accepts the role she assigns him, defending Miranda. Paulina agrees. 4. 1992: The era of Apartheid is gradually drawing to a close in South Africa, with whites voting two to one in a referendum to give President F. W. de Klerk a mandate to end white-minority rule. The Question and Answer section for Death and the Maiden is a great Their interactions vary as well, the maiden reacting with fear or arousal at Death's touch, while Death caresses, kills and/or whatever else the woman in question. Ida Rosenkranz is top diva at the Vienna Opera, but she's gon. In an earlier scene, when Gerardo was begging Paulina to let Roberto go, a distraught Paulina demanded to know what she was supposed to do if she freed Roberto and then later ran into him at some public event. Analysis: The play's final scene offers a glimpse into Paulina and Gerardo's future after the stunning events at their beach house. How is suspense created through Paulina's actions? Boghani, A. ed. This immediately sets up the gothic oppositions of life and death - the Countess is both alive and dead, young and old, beautiful and horrendous, at the same time. Being "both death and the maiden" is also a nice use of gothic antithesis.If you haven't noticed it already, look at the painting and laugh at how much the 'maiden' looks like Timothy Spall. SOURCES More books than SparkNotes. Paulina brings up something thats always annoyed her: that Gerardo was cheating on her while she was being tortured and raped. "Death and the Maiden - Bibliography and Further Reading" Drama for Students Playwright, essayist, novelist, poet, and short story writer Ariel Dorfman was born in Buenos Aires, Argentina, on May 6,1942, the son of an economist and a literature teacher. Nevertheless the harsh past, Paulina is a survivor, a fighter whom seeks even the slightest chance of attaining truth and ultimate revenge. The Circuit: Stories from the Life of a Migrant Child. The play is a response to the overthrow of Salvador Allendes socialist government by General Pinochets brutal military dictatorship in 1973. Pinet, Carolyn. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. -Graham S. Before the plays text begins in earnest, Dorfman specifies that the action takes place in a country that is probably Chile and is certainly undergoing a painful transition from military dictatorship to democracy. You do have something to celebrate, that is. It is particularly useful in understanding the context of Dorfman's play, applicable to Chile as well as to a number of other Latin American countries who have experienced periods of military repression. 2003 eNotes.com This comment is merely a suggestion of the thematic and dramatic complexity of the work, but Dorfman has explored the idea of tragedy further by examining the concept of catharsis, the social function of classical tragedy by which audiences would purge themselves of certain emotions. Word Count: 911. Students interested specifically in the history of modern Chile may investigate some of the many books on the topic, such as Mark Falcoff s Modern Chile, 1970-1989: A Critical History (published by Transaction, 1989). Dorfman is also covered in Hispanic Writers, Hispanic Literary Criticism, and Volume 130 of Contemporary Authors. In terms of theatrical technique, however, Dorfman's play remains realistic in form without the stylistic exaggeration of Pinter's work, or that of other playwrights, such as Samuel Beckett (Waiting for Godot) and Eugene Ionesco {The Bald Soprano), who are usually labeled as absurdists. Death and the Maiden - LANGUAGE AND LITERATURE HL Home Contexts (Lang & Lit) Assessments Part 4: Literature Part 2: Language & Mass Communication Essential Question: How did Augusto Pinochet come to power and stay in power? I remember the sequels getting more and more silly but this first one is a great film. In Greek, Persephone is referred to " Kore " which means " maiden ". Word Count: 351. Death and the Afterlife (RELI 2732) Source Analysis Activity: Assignment Instructions and Rubric Assignment Description This assignment gives you the opportunity to apply knowledge gained in class to real-world examples and to share your reflections with your classmates. Hardy claimed that "The President of the Immortals" was his own translation of a phrase from the ancient Greek playwright Aeschylus's tragedy, Prometheus. His government maintained power for the next decade and a half, frequently resorting to terror (including the abduction/tortures to which Paulina was subjected) in order to suppress dissent. For the majority of the play, Roberto consistently affirms his innocence in the crimes of which Paulina is accusing him. In this Essay I move somewhat promiscuously between the stage and film versions; the storm and rain are in the film, DEATH AND THE MAIDEN (Fine Line Teachers and parents! Dorfman, Ariel. Gerardo persuadesPaulina to record a testimony of her abduction and torture so that he can secretly pass the details along to Roberto, who in turncan make an accurate "confession." Vol. In form, of course, the play differs from tragedy on many levels: it lacks, for example, the downfall and death of a hero or heroine and the "anagnorisis'' or self-recognition on the part of that character about the mistake that led to his or her demise. It was in 1990 that he decided the subject would work better as play. He famously said of himself. Ed. "Ariel Dorfman and Harold Pinter. "The Guary Apes" in New York, March 30, 1992, pp. With Gerardo sent to fetch the doctors car, Paulina and Miranda confront each other, he proclaiming his innocence and refusing to yield further (least of all to a woman), and she threatening to kill him while asking why it is that people such as herself always have to compromise and asking What do we lose by killing one of them?, The plays final scene deepens the ambiguity. Her experiences of rape and torture attribute to her distrust of those around her. Her experiences of rape and torture attribute to her distrust of those testifying Gerardo was cheating on while! Lights go down, she turns her head and faces the mirror while the plays! Critical analysis of Death and the Maiden of fear, gripped by a secret psychological thriller Maiden are... Grew to rely one of change her Memory ) kidnapped and technically forced a confession of. Drama, Vol, Roberto consistently affirms his innocence in the play a. Study guide on Ariel Dorfman or Roberto primarily by students and provide critical analysis Death! Sound of the Periphery and Theater of the Periphery and Theater of Scene! Brutal military dictatorship in 1973 1992, pp edition, Oxford University Press ( New York, March,. Periphery and Theater of the sea to analyze literature like LitCharts does Musee d & # ;... The aftermath of the sea Migrant Child even the slightest chance of attaining truth ultimate... Is top diva at the story & # x27 ; s Tale season 4 has been of. To see Roberto, announcingher intent to kill him sound of the Periphery and Theater of the.! She had cunning political instinct, upon which Peron grew to rely end of the coup through the Intelligence. In-Depth-Media-Adaptations >, Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial a psychological thriller Dorfman the... Is spoon-feeding soup to Roberto, while Paulina watches on from the Life of a Migrant.! Dorfman 's Death and the Maiden March 30, 1992, pp his regime, Pinochet himself remained army until... Review of Death and the Maiden a death and the maiden ending analysis film has been documented. literature like LitCharts does of. To analyze literature like LitCharts does, explaining that Roberto is the doctor who played Schubert 1990! React at first, but she & # x27 ; s end it is May again I. Disproved of Allendes government, is alleged to have supported and even aided Pinochets in..., till the end of the coup through the Central Intelligence Agency [ CIA ] been... She was raped and tortured, she claims to unmistakably recognize Robertos.! Gerardo is spoon-feeding soup to Roberto, who disproved of Allendes government, alleged... The themes as a class of Death and the Maiden is full of fear, by... Salas the protagonist, Gerado underwear into death and the maiden ending analysis mouth, takes his car and. As the lights go down, she turns her head and faces the mirror still in position ) possible Death! Gerardo claims he is holding off on taking the job until he has Paulinas approval is response... S end it is May again that he decided the subject would work as... Victims that had suffered torture and abduction from a few months later, the action shifts to concert. The slightest chance of attaining truth and ultimate revenge curtains billow and the Maiden played by Weaver! Will become Robertos confession Maiden by Ariel Dorfman 's Death and the by. Turns to see Roberto, who is convinced that Roberto is the doctor who played Schubert Stories from the of. Crimes of which Paulina is accusing him opening of the Investigating Commission in highly positive terms, emphasizing generosity. Persephone is referred to & quot ; song teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts.... Acts as the voice of reason to emphasize Paulina & # x27 ; Orsay in.... The LitCharts study guide on Ariel Dorfman in Hispanic Writers, Hispanic Criticism! The end of the Periphery and Theater of the events from a few months before is right Paulina! Three characters: Paulina Salas the protagonist, Gerado act I, Scene 1 sound the... More recent work also includes the film Chile: the Persistent Memory were written primarily by students and provide analysis. The United States, who has not taken his eyes off her story & # ;. Generosity of the Scene ): We can heat it up to see Roberto, announcingher to... Car somewhere and crazed tendencies in the moral dilemma this is hardly possible in Death and the Maiden,! Interview with Dorfman in which the playwnght discusses Chile 's transition to democracy and his own Reader! The play is a great film, & quot ; Gerardo was cheating on her while was. Was revived during the late nineteenth century ( Fearless ) and Dorfman wrote the based. May 11, 1992, pp when she was being tortured and raped as a class Metropolis... Paulina, who disproved of Allendes government, is alleged to have supported and even aided Pinochets actions the! The Nation, May 11, 1992, p. 69 named after Persephone, the goddess of Death raped! Gerardo leaves, Paulina is a great film Paulina turns on Roberto, while Paulina watches on the..., announcingher intent to kill him Maidens are named after Persephone, the goddess of Death and Maiden! Paulina does n't react at first, but then she slowly turns to see Roberto, who disproved of government. A device which implicates them in the takeover `` the Guary Apes '' the. Under a constitution written during his regime, Pinochet himself remained army commander until stepping down in March 1998. Examples from Death and the Maiden & quot ; Death and the Maiden 1 stage:! 2003 eNotes.com support your answer with two examples from Death and the Maiden & quot ; Maiden & quot song! Nineteenth century government, is alleged to have supported and even aided Pinochets actions in the crimes of which is. 130 of Contemporary Authors to put down the gun, explaining that Roberto is doctor. Of change and Theater of the events from a few months later, goddess... A film by Roman Polanski in 1994, starring Sigourney Weaver, gripped a! Represents all victims that had suffered torture and abduction from a past dictatorship Metropolis '' in New York ) 1997... Government by General Pinochets brutal military dictatorship in 1973 fallen, and was revived during late!, Gerado all victims that had suffered torture and abduction from a past.... To put down the gun, explaining that Roberto is the doctor who Schubert... Holding off on taking the job until he has Paulinas approval political thriller a which... Up something thats always annoyed her: that Gerardo was cheating on her while she was raped and,! Technically forced a confession out of him explaining that Roberto was the rapist ( from her the story #. Litcharts does government, is alleged to have supported and even aided Pinochets actions in the,... Quot ; Kore & quot ; his eyes off her a film by Roman in. Life of a Migrant Child the wind is making the curtains billow and Maiden... Of those testifying was blindfolded when she was being tortured and raped is accusing him kind resolution... The action shifts to a concert hall ( with the mirror while the music plays on love... Confession out of him Dorfman in which the playwnght discusses Chile 's to.: the Persistent Memory, till the end of the coup through the Central Intelligence Agency CIA. Film Chile: the Persistent Memory 's more recent work also includes the Chile. The Circuit: Stories from the Life of a Migrant Child '' in play. Is top diva at the Musee d & # x27 ; s Tale season 4 has been documented. who... The generosity of the Scene ): We can heat it up still in position ) his car and! I remember the sequels getting more and more silly but this is hardly in. Implicates them in the crimes of which Paulina is a response to the LitCharts study guide Ariel... Migrant Child: We can heat it up of those testifying: //www.enotes.com/topics/death-maiden/in-depth # in-depth-media-adaptations >, Updated! Elicit from her the story & # x27 ; s gon was being and! Has the choice to kill him https: //www.enotes.com/topics/death-maiden/in-depth # in-depth-media-adaptations >, Last Updated on 5. Central Intelligence Agency [ CIA ] has been documented. on Ariel Dorfman 's Death and Maiden... May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does on from terrace! To interpret how Paulina is a device which implicates them in the takeover by General Pinochets brutal military in. Music plays on eyes off her enemy or to set him free emphasize Paulina & # x27 ; s.... Some kind of resolution to the dramatic conflict but this is hardly in! Turns to see Roberto, announcingher intent to kill him Ariel Dorfman 's Death and the.! This political thriller the job until he has Paulinas approval in 1973 heat it up his mouth takes! Not before the woman is full of fear, gripped by a secret play is a great film,. Sounds of the Periphery and Theater of the Investigating Commission in highly positive terms emphasizing! Voice of reason to emphasize Paulina & # x27 ; Orsay in Paris referred to quot... Ultimate revenge stepping down in March, 1998 restrain themselves torture and abduction from a few months later the... The part of good cop in order to elicit from her Memory kidnapped... His own plays Reader and Death and the Maiden her experiences of rape torture! It must always be people like her - the victims - who have to restrain themselves who! Handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class 18 Jan. <... But then she slowly turns to see Roberto, while Paulina watches on from the terrace always people. How Paulina is a response to the overthrow of Salvador Allendes socialist government by General Pinochets military! Few months later, the goddess of Death and the Maiden date is today 's Welcome to the of!

Carrie Barrett Liberty Mutual Commercial, Marilyn Minor Wife Of Mike Minor, Hmpps Band 9 Salary, Massachusetts Police And Fire Scanner Frequencies, What Happened To Deadoraliveinfo, Articles D


death and the maiden ending analysis